“Understanding ourselves, navigating the world around us, making sense of others, and recognising the impact we have on them. Because who are we, really, if not shaped by one another?“
Happy Thursday, everyone. I’m Shaida Darian, a Business and Organisational Psychologist. I’m fascinated by three questions: Why does this happen? What can we do about it? And when should we act? Join me down the rabbit hole. With any luck, we’ll find Wonderland.
This week in workplace whiplash 🌀
When Crisis Hits, the Right Leadership Style Changes.
Research involving 72 teams in simulated crises found that directive leadership improved decision speed and accuracy in familiar emergencies, while participative leadership improved accuracy in unfamiliar situations. Effective leadership depends on recognising what the crisis demands.Fast Decisions Don't Mean Less Thinking.
Research by Kathleen Eisenhardt found that faster strategic decision-makers used more real-time information, evaluated more alternatives and sought advice. Decisiveness is not about thinking less, but making informed decisions without unnecessary delay.The Best Leadership Style Today May Not Work Tomorrow.
A longitudinal study of 60 teams found that directive leadership supported stronger initial performance, while empowering leadership produced greater improvements over time. Effective leaders know when to take charge and when to give others autonomy.
🤝 This edition is kindly brought to you by HR Partner
Running a business is expensive enough without your HR software throwing in a surprise price hike.
HR Partner helps small and mighty teams manage everything from hiring and onboarding to leave, performance reviews and employee records, all in one place.
We're a small business too, so we know every dollar counts. We think you should be able to plan ahead without being tied to a long-term contract.
That's why new customers who subscribe by December 31, 2026, get two years of price certainty, with no price increases for 24 months.
Thursday reflections
A few years ago, I sat in the boardroom of a large enterprise facing new international regulations that threatened its distribution network. I’m Shaida Darian, a business and organisational psychologist exploring how leadership styles shape decision-making, team performance and organisational effectiveness.
In that meeting, senior executives debated their options for nearly three hours. Legal wanted further review, commercial leaders pushed for immediate customer communication, and operations struggled to agree on the next steps. The CEO encouraged further discussion, hoping consensus would emerge.
Meanwhile, shipments remained frozen, customers were growing concerned, and losses were mounting.
Then the Chief Operating Officer stood up and said,
“We are out of time. I am making the operational call now. Here are the three decisions we are executing within the next sixty minutes. If this strategy fails, hold me solely accountable to the board.”
He hadn't dismissed anyone's expertise. He had listened, assessed the competing priorities, and recognised that the situation demanded action.
Within hours, the team had established clear priorities and begun stabilising operations.
That experience reinforced an important lesson: Decisive leadership is not the opposite of collaborative leadership. It is knowing when to listen, when to take charge, and when to accept responsibility for the outcome.
Which brings me to the question: “Are we developing leaders who know when to take charge, or simply teaching them how to collaborate?”
🧠The organisational psychology lens
The ability to adapt leadership behaviour to changing circumstances is one of the most important capabilities organisations need to develop.
Modern leadership development places considerable emphasis on collaboration, empathy and empowerment. These capabilities are essential, but they are not sufficient. When a crisis strikes, leaders must also be able to make difficult decisions, establish direction and mobilise people under pressure.
During a crisis, uncertainty increases cognitive demands, priorities compete, and teams can struggle to coordinate. Clear direction becomes particularly valuable. Decisive leaders reduce ambiguity by establishing priorities, clarifying responsibilities and taking accountability for difficult decisions.
This is where decisive leadership differs from authoritarianism. Taking charge does not mean dismissing expertise or silencing disagreement. It means knowing when sufficient input has been gathered, making a timely decision and giving people the clarity to act.
Organisations therefore need to develop behavioural flexibility: the ability to adapt leadership behaviour to changing circumstances. Crisis simulations, clearly defined decision-making authority, and experience working under uncertainty can help leaders develop this capability.
The goal is not to replace collaborative leadership with command and control. It is to develop leaders who can do both and have the judgement to know when each is needed.
When a crisis demands action, what is the biggest challenge for leaders?
🚀What this means for leaders
Recognise When to Take Charge. Assess the urgency, consequences of delay and time available for consultation. When immediate action is necessary, establish clear priorities, assign responsibilities and set deadlines.
Make Decisions Without Perfect Information. Identify the three most critical facts you need, consult the relevant experts and set a deadline for making the decision. Act, monitor the results and adjust as new information emerges.
Be Decisive Without Being Authoritarian. Invite challenges before making the decision, explain your reasoning and communicate what needs to happen, by whom and when. Once the decision is made, ensure everyone understands their role.
Practise Leading Under Pressure. Run crisis simulations with your leadership team. Introduce unexpected disruptions, impose time constraints and require individuals to make and defend decisions. Review what worked, what failed and where authority was unclear.
Leadership is not about choosing between collaboration and authority. It is about having the judgement to know when each is needed, the courage to make difficult decisions and the accountability to see them through. When a crisis strikes, people need more than a leader who listens. They need someone prepared to lead.
💬 Final thoughts
Effective leadership is not about choosing between authority and collaboration. It is about having the judgement to recognise what the situation demands.
The strongest leaders know when to listen and draw on collective wisdom, but also when to step forward, make difficult decisions and take responsibility for the outcome. Leadership is not defined by how much authority we exercise, but by knowing when and how to use it.
How's the depth of today's edition?
If something here speaks to you, I’d love to hear it.
Until next week,
Shaida
P.S. Where do your pre-hire criteria stop matching what your team surely values and rewards? Reply to this email and let me know.
If you’re new here, I’m over the moon you’ve joined us! To help me craft content that’s actually useful (and not just noise in your inbox), I’d love it if you took 1 minute to answer this quick survey below. Your insights help shape everything I write.
✨ Insane Media is more than one voice
💡 Dive into our other newsletters - where psychology meets the founders, creator economy, e-commerce marketing, and AI founders.






