Parental leave is a career risk? still?

This week in workplace whiplash 🌀

From relentless notifications to leadership double standards, here’s what had HR teams doing a double‑take this week:

• 📧 Workers burning the midnight oil
  After‑hours gatherings (post‑8 pm) are up 16%, and the burnout buzz is at a 10‑year peak.
   👉 WSJ 

• 💻 Young pros stuck in ‘infinite workdays’
  Microsoft’s latest Work Trends Index reports 40% of employees check emails at 6 am, and evening alerts are hiking into the late hours.
   👉 The Guardian 

• 🏦 HSBC considers office-only returns
  HSBC is weighing a global three‑days‑in‑office rule for collaboration consistency - mirroring industry-wide hybrid rollbacks.
   👉 Financial Times 

• 📈 Managers avoiding promotions
  New research reveals 55% of UK staff have turned down leadership roles - double the global average. The bottleneck? Too much managerial stress.
   👉 The Times 

These stories underline a critical trend: even robust policies (like parental leave) won’t work if culture, workload, and leadership don’t support them…

“I was warned that there’d be consequences if I use their full parental leave policy.”

That’s the title of this now-viral Reddit post from a new dad in the US. It’s a punch to the gut for anyone who thought workplaces had moved on.

Despite being eligible for 12 weeks of paid leave, the poster shared that HR implied there would be “consequences” for using the full allowance. The suggestion was clear: taking what you’re entitled to might make you look less committed. It’s the kind of subtle penalty women have long faced - just with a modern twist.

But this isn’t just a one-off Reddit story. It points to a bigger issue: the lingering stigma around actually using parental leave.

🤝 Supported by WorkBright

Compliance can feel complicated. With regulations changing at a rapid pace, it’s difficult for HR pros to keep up and cut through the noise. What’s actually required, and what can HR leaders actually do about it? WorkBright’s webinar has the answers. Chapelle Ryon, CEO of WorkBright, and Kimberley Best-Robidoux, veteran immigration attorney, will lead the action-oriented discussion—be sure to save your virtual seat.

🍼 Why parental leave still feels risky

Even where generous policies exist, many employees worry that taking leave will signal they’re not serious about their careers. And there’s data to back that up:

• A UK-based Pregnant Then Screwed survey found that 70% of dads who shortened their leave did so due to financial pressure or fear of negative consequences.

• McKinsey and Lean In reports that 20% of women, and 10% of men, say parental leave has negatively affected their careers.

• According to the Fatherhood Institute, in the UK, almost a third of fathers took no paternity leave after the birth of their child

The message is clear: even when the policy exists, taking it can feel risky.

🫥 When policies and culture clash

We’re in the era of baby emojis all over LinkedIn - #FathersDay posts galore - but when someone actually uses their parental leave, often the response is muted or absent.

A recent Financial News investigation confirms that even in elite finance firms, fathers who take extended paternity leave can face real pushback. One senior staffer at a major bank quoted “I was given the very strong impression that… by taking paternity leave, I wasn’t showing commitment to the job.” He was made redundant four days after his paternity leave started. 

Behavioural science shows the power of modelling: if senior leaders don’t visibly use their leave, or face backlash when they do, the assumption becomes clear - maybe you shouldn’t either.

🧠 The hidden cost of parental leave anxiety

There’s a moment many new parents know well: the creeping anxiety before you even apply for leave. Will this hurt my career? Will my manager still take me seriously? Should I just wait until the next promotion cycle?

What feels personal is actually a workplace risk. A recent study by Cariloop found that 73% of new parents considered quitting after taking parental leave, with many pointing to poor planning and lack of manager support as the final straw. Even more worrying? 36% actually did quit.

And on the other side? Over two-thirds of managers admitted they felt totally unprepared to support team members through leave transitions. So we’re not just dropping the ball - we’re pretending it’s someone else’s job to catch it.

If you're wondering why your post-leave returnees aren’t sticking around, the problem might not be the parents. It might be the silence around them.

✅ What can HR actually do?

Here’s the hard part. Having a policy isn’t the same as making it usable. If taking leave feels like a red flag for your future, the policy isn’t working.

So what does help?

• Leaders need to take leave (and not be penalised for doing so). If no one at the top uses the policy, others won’t feel safe doing so either.

• Be transparent. Report uptake across teams and roles. This shows what’s really happening.

• Train your managers. They should support, not just tolerate, leave.

• Use behavioural nudges. Make full leave the default, not something employees have to ask for.

• Share real stories. Visibility helps normalise it. If people never hear that someone took 12 weeks and returned stronger, they’ll assume it’s not possible.

And no, “we’ll let line managers handle it” doesn’t cut it. That’s how bias happens.

💬 Final thoughts

Parental leave policies are standard now. The real question is whether people feel safe enough to use them.

Until staff can take time to care for a new baby without guilt or fear of being sidelined, nothing has really changed. Policies are only as powerful as the culture they sit in.

It's time to make sure both are aligned.